Jim Bishop
EF4
Anyone remember Sept 16 2006 (SD)? How 'bout October 9, 2001 (OK)?
We should be so lucky to have October 9, 2001 happen next week! What a historic day.
Anyone remember Sept 16 2006 (SD)? How 'bout October 9, 2001 (OK)?
You received criticism for your post because you were making a forecast, or at least a wish cast, based soly on one run of the GFS Operational model looking out about 15 days! Did you check to see if there was any consistency? There wasn't. In fact over the last week the GFS has displayed incredible run to run inconsistecies. It's usually not wise to trust the GFS Operational model beyond day 10...and this time of the year it's an extra fail to do so.
Out of curiosity, I went back and looked at the 12z Sept 14 GFS run (over one week ago), and for the Sept 29/30 timeframe it was forecasting a ridge over the West and a trough over the Plains and Great Lakes. That is not likely to verify at this point based on the current ensembles. So I'm not sure what one run you saw, but the point is anyone can look at one fantasy GFS run and report it online, but it does no good without support from other models or teleconnections, etc.
Notice when I started the thread I emphasized that it was too far out to trust anything other than that a trough would develop. One did in fact, it just completely missed the plains!Exactly! The GFS more than a couple days out is ALL OVER THE PLACE from run to run and has been for a long time...which is why I always laugh when threads are started up, or posts are made based on, like you said, 1 run of the GFS that is 300 hours out. Take a look at this thread, it was started 1 month ago based on a couple of decent GFS runs, and well, how'd that work out? That about sums it up right there.
Notice when I started the thread I emphasized that it was too far out to trust anything other than that a trough would develop. One did in fact, it just completely missed the plains!
Exactly. The pattern looks like it is going to become very favorable for a few good chase setups, possibly as soon as next week. When, where, and how chaseable they are is still up for grabs, but this is very encouraging, and I'm going to be watching closely.But forget the details for a second. The point here is there are going to be a few storm chasing setups in the southern to central plains beginning mid next week through next weekend (Sept 30 - Oct 4) that produce some discrete storms and supercells, and potentially tornadoes. And from the overall pattern I'm seeing there should be a few more setups the week following Oct 4, as we head into mid October.
Psssst! 252 hour GFS. I am calling off work now Of course I am not that naive but lets see what happens. As TSC says above it is certainly taking an encouraging trend.
Look at the 180 Hour!
You received criticism for your post because you were making a forecast, or at least a wish cast, based soly on one run of the GFS Operational model looking out about 15 days! Did you check to see if there was any consistency? There wasn't. In fact over the last week the GFS has displayed incredible run to run inconsistecies. It's usually not wise to trust the GFS Operational model beyond day 10...and this time of the year it's an extra fail to do so.
Out of curiosity, I went back and looked at the 12z Sept 14 GFS run (over one week ago), and for the Sept 29/30 timeframe it was forecasting a ridge over the West and a trough over the Plains and Great Lakes. That is not likely to verify at this point based on the current ensembles. So I'm not sure what one run you saw, but the point is anyone can look at one fantasy GFS run and report it online, but it does no good without support from other models or teleconnections, etc.
Hey Adam, I wouldn't worry about the exact day at this point. For one thing, I think GFS can be a little too progressive with big systems like this. For another, 12z ECMWF shows the best day to be Oct 1. But I expect even that will change...looking at the 18z today it looks like sept 30th is the only decent chase day...and go figure thats the one day I cannot chase
Dont you think I know all of this already? Every person knows the GFS cant be trusted entirely that far out..Im sick of someone telling me that every single time. I wouldn't have even mentioned it unless I saw it in more than one run. God forbid someone chimes in with a intelligent observations about things they see or trends they notice...too much to ask I guess until SPC mentions it in the day 4-8 these days.
It showed up in more than one run, maybe not the majority but it still happened...unfortunately I only saved one image which I posted on my blog on sept 14th and go figure the dates are chopped off but it looks like the 18z run...id love to waste my time and sift through all the runs looking for the rest but id rather not argue over a moot point.
what really matters is there has been trends towards an active pattern and thats a good thing
although looking at the 18z today it looks like sept 30th is the only decent chase day...and go figure thats the one day I cannot chase.