Good day all,
Hispanola (Dom Republic and Haiti) will un-doubtedly kill this thing becuase you have terrain nearly 11,000 feet high there. Even if the system goes north of there, the south winds on its east side will ingest dry (subsident down-slope) air (anyone remember debbie back in Aug 2000? It passed Puerto Rico and ingested the dry air from the mountains near Dominican Rep and weakened to a TD then a wave in only 24 hours).
Also, to my suprise as well - since this thing looks to impressive on the satellite, it is all but just a very strong wave. The circulation might be in the mid-levels (near 700 MB) and outflow / upper air is impressive ... However, a LLC is only starting to get organized.
This is why a satellite image is not enough ... You have to fly a plane in-situ and actually measure it (like the USAF did yesterday and found no depression yet, also to their suprise). Radar at San Juan also shows little right now.
If this thing tracks like Ernesto did in 2006, it would be just that ... A tropical depression hitting FL with NHC hyping it way out of proportion and un-necessarily scare-ing lots of people. I remember Ernesto in '06 ... Was so close to chasing it (I was living in St Louis at the time) ... Glad I didn't because I just did not see it strengthening over the mountains in Cuba like the NHC promised it would ;-(
Upper level winds can be perfect for development, but these things will NOT form over land, period.
Also, mountains are the worst "enemy" to the low-level structure of a tropical system due to dry air (subsidence / downslope) and disruption of the circulation due to drag.
The big threat (which is actually MORE common with a weak system) is the rains ... In Hispanola this can be very bad (flash floods) ... remember? Which storm killed more people (Jeanne in FL at 120 MPH on Sep 25, 2004 = 20 killed Vs Jeanne in Haiti earlier that week at 50 MPH = 3000+ killed in floods).