I'm sort of biased on the Subaru. Most any of them. The new Impreza gets 38mpg highway, while having full time AWD.
See, I've been driving in the great plains for 37 years. You need AWD or 4x4 just so you don't have to park with two wheels on the pavement.
But I don't drive a Bronco, or Jeep, or giant Tundra because I like the handling of the Subaru. 95% of the time you'll just be... driving. Interstate and, OMG, Oklahoma state highways. If you spend any amount of time out here, you'll realize that people can't drive very well. We go 5-10mph over the limit, most always. We enjoy cutting a corner, across the lane you shouldn't go into, because it's like a NASCAR apex turn. We do this to such an extent that often the left turn lane signal is triggered, when it was only the corner cutter. In Norman we've rewarded this anarchy. I've seen two intersections where the left turn lane stop bar has been moved back 2 car lengths, to allow folks to cut through that lane! Amazing. The stop bar before the crosswalk is mistaken for the 'signal detection stripe', and of course you have to drive over that to trigger the signal, right?
Several times in my driving for sparks, or tornadoes, most always quite leisurely, I've had near wrecks that my Subaru Outback saved me. Excellent braking, even with only 2 discs and a couple drums. Nimble, as turning around the trouble is helpful.
And I do a ton of boot-leg turns. This is a 2 point turn really. You're stopped on the sholder, see that there's a tornado there, or baseballs, or downed lines, etc so u-turn. You go into Reverse and turn the wheel so that the passenger front wheel is just on the safe part. Really bad to turn too sharply or this wheel falls off into the bar ditch. Then tighten up the turn going backwards as this wheel stays almost in danger. You'll whip around fast, putting rear passenger wheel almost in the other ditch. Turn the wheel right full and you should be able to be now going the opposite direction. You only "back up" down a road if you need to keep the tornado in the dashcam sight, and didn't think to have a rear facing one too. Orrrr, you need to add some 'flare' to a tornado. You know, jazz it up a bit...
I do have to say I'm getting tired of having to navigate around huge Ford F550's with TV station shrink wrap. They seem to need to clog roads by parking sideways ON the road in order the dashcam feed get to the TV station. Or web. They fly past my nimble Outback that's going 5mph over the limit, at 20mph over the limit.
I chased just fine in a 1999 Saturn Coupe. FWD. Horrible on mud. Even a little rain. But was a fine tornado interceptor. Extremely good handling, almost as good as a subaru. Got 30-35mpg highway. AND it had an Air Conditioner! But I shot storms from a distance including May3rd , 1999, as I didn't feel the need to get my icon in under the meso with the other icons on the map. I did get radar over 4800 baud tethered cell phone connection though. Never got a hail break until its 8th yr.
But for safety, and now so that you don't have to park ON the highway, definitely get AWD or 4x4. BTW, 4x4=16.
