Tim Vasquez
EF5
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2003
- Messages
- 3,411
There is a new set of forums on Stormtrack, which are hidden from view. When you log out, you will be able to see them. They are being kept out of sight because we realize that a lot of Stormtrack users may not be interested in them.
For a good chunk of the week, myself and the moderators have been discussing the issue of people we are turning away. We are obviously not able to approve all memberships, because Stormtrack requires chase experience or educational credentials. There are a lot of armchair chasers, enthusiasts, photographers, and spotters who don't quite make the cut, or are discouraged from sending in their membership essay.
So tonight we've set up the board so that users who register and reply to the confirmation message will be able to immediately post in these new forums, which we are calling Stormwatch. We have also approved 17 members who had registered since yesterday (I have no idea how many of them sent in essays).
Nobody has the slightest idea if this will work. On one hand, these users may not have too much interest in chasing or may find Stormtrack too intimidating, and may be happy with the newbie boards. On the other hand, the users may resent not getting a "full fledged" pass into Stormtrack. We don't really know. So this is being run as a sort of experiment to see if this idea can work somehow. If it is counterproductive we'll be getting rid of it. If it works, though, it may attract participation from our experienced chasers, and it will have some really useful educational benefits.
As far as all you are concerned, the question is how you want this Stormwatch board to appear. Here are the options that are feasible with our current software:
Tim
For a good chunk of the week, myself and the moderators have been discussing the issue of people we are turning away. We are obviously not able to approve all memberships, because Stormtrack requires chase experience or educational credentials. There are a lot of armchair chasers, enthusiasts, photographers, and spotters who don't quite make the cut, or are discouraged from sending in their membership essay.
So tonight we've set up the board so that users who register and reply to the confirmation message will be able to immediately post in these new forums, which we are calling Stormwatch. We have also approved 17 members who had registered since yesterday (I have no idea how many of them sent in essays).
Nobody has the slightest idea if this will work. On one hand, these users may not have too much interest in chasing or may find Stormtrack too intimidating, and may be happy with the newbie boards. On the other hand, the users may resent not getting a "full fledged" pass into Stormtrack. We don't really know. So this is being run as a sort of experiment to see if this idea can work somehow. If it is counterproductive we'll be getting rid of it. If it works, though, it may attract participation from our experienced chasers, and it will have some really useful educational benefits.
As far as all you are concerned, the question is how you want this Stormwatch board to appear. Here are the options that are feasible with our current software:
- Stormwatch is invisible, viewable only when you log out and view the site as a guest
- Stormwatch is visible only by requesting a "hybridized" account from an admin
- Stormwatch is visible normally on the list of boards (you can actually make the entire forum disappear by viewing only the Stormtrack Forums category -- http://www.stormtrack.org/forum/index.php?showforum=20)
Tim