• A friendly and periodic reminder of the rules we use for fostering high SNR and quality conversation and interaction at Stormtrack: Forum rules

    P.S. - Nothing specific happened to prompt this message! No one is in trouble, there are no flame wars in effect, nor any inappropriate conversation ongoing. This is being posted sitewide as a casual refresher.

Oklahoma Weather Drone Use Could Provide Tornado Warnings

Steve Miller

Owner Emeritus
Staff member
Supporter
NORMAN, Oklahoma - New research here in Oklahoma is designed to give people more of a heads-up before severe weather strikes, making storm season safer. Part of the work is happening at the University of Oklahoma.

What if a drone - or unmanned aerial vehicle as the forecasters prefer to call them - could mean much earlier warnings or warnings where there are now none? OU meteorology professor Phillip Chilson and researchers at the National Weather Center are using hobbyist-style remote airplanes. The airplanes are about 2-pounds and 2-feet long with speeds in excess of 100 mph and decked out with hi-tech sensors.

"This is groundbreaking, this is a game changer," OU Professor of Meteorology Phillip Chilson said. "When you have these different technologies that come around once in a while that really shake up the whole nature of the type of research we're doing. How often can you say that you go out and play with toys as part of your research and do something meaningful for science?"

Right now, when making forecasts, NWS meteorologists use radar, satellites and balloons to check conditions in the upper and middle atmosphere. Conditions at the surface where we live are observed by instruments and people. But there is a small gap in the lower atmosphere where a UAV could make a big difference.

Moore, 2013: The official warning was 16 minutes before the tornado hit Newcastle

Broken Arrow, 2013: A two-minute advance warning of a small, but damaging tornado.

Joplin, 2011: Sirens first sounded 24 minutes before the tornado that killed 161 people

Quapaw, 2014: No official advance tornado warning - only a thunderstorm warning 12 minutes before touchdown.

"It allows you to get to areas that are inaccessible," said Chilson.

Some experts predict that ability could increase tornado warnings from 20 to 60 minutes. The problem now is when conditions are ripe for storms, forecasters don't know exactly where or when one will trigger a tornado.

"I think of it as being a whole bed of tightly coiled springs just waiting for something to happen," Chilson said. "What triggers that spring to release its energy - fly up in the atmosphere - to trigger the other springs around it? That's the part that's difficult."

But he believes UAVs will give a better understanding of what's really happening leading to quicker calls on when and where a storm may turn violent. While there's real excitement in the possibilities of the research, what will it look like in the future when it comes to keeping you and your family safe? There's debate, even inside Norman's National Weather Center.

"These are experiments that have yet to be done, to my knowledge," said Dr. Greg Carbin, meteorologist at the National Storm Prediction Center. "And until they are, you can't make definitive statements that they'll drastically change the state of forecasting."

The hold-up to learning more is the FAA, which is nearly grounding research efforts while it studies how manned and unmanned aircraft can exist in harmony in the nation's airspace. But dreamer and realist agree, any new tool that could help save lives is welcome.

"You know, it'll be another piece of the puzzle," Carbin said. "We might be able to fit some puzzle pieces together and better predict what's going to happen."

"It will improve forecasts, increase lead times and increase the general safety of the public," said Dr. Phillip Chilson, OU Professor of Meteorology. "There's not a shadow of a doubt in my mind that if we have the capability to fly these types of platforms and make measurements of the lower atmosphere, that it will improve forecasts, increase lead times and increase the general safety of the public."

Back in February, the FAA issued its proposed rules for the use of drones by businesses.

See An Overview Of The Proposed FAA Rules For Drones

The OU researchers tell us it's a good first step as they wait to see how the FAA will regulate their use of UAVs. OU, Oklahoma State University and two other universities have submitted a joint weather UAV plan to the National Science Foundation.
 
Greg Carbin with the win for "putting the professor's baseless claims in place -- but in a polite way" :)
 
What about hail? Wouldn't it take one errant baseball to destroy this thing? I suppose it could be useful though, especially for those tornadoes that occur in the jungles.
 
There's no real information about what it is they intend to measure which is going to make these claims a reality. Given that science still struggles to explain tornadogenesis it's rather difficult to go out and measure something when we don't really know what we should be measuring. I suppose a network of these things flying around a supercell making measurements might yield interesting information but I imagine several would also become large hail nuclei!
 
The proposal beats the hell out of toy rockets and party balloons :)

I do believe there is some value, but I've flown experimental drones for a client in bad weather and it's not an easy feat. I'm not sure of the ceiling limits they would need. That could be a limiting factor. You would likely need some type of remotely piloted military drone to do the job or disposable drones with instrument packages flown by legitimate scientists.

W.
 
My chase team here in Michigan uses a drone, and it allows for a much clearer view of the base, and helps us pin point hot spots within a storm. I'm glad to see this may become common practice.
 
I believe they would be using the drone plane to strictly measure pre-storm boundary layer environments on days where there is a possible threat. The plan is to fill the gap between sonde launches but the plane can only go up so far (PBL height maybe). It has a pitot tube to measure vertical wind profiles. The plane is also equipped with a thermometer and hygrometer. My peers did their capstone this year using this plane and Dr. Chilson as the mentor. I think it can be very useful if it works properly and measures the correct wind profile. Could be useful for find low-level shear. Now all it needs is a probe missile launcher! ha
 
My collaborators and I have identified a feature (we call a streamwise vorticity current) in a simulated tornadic supercell that perhaps could be a feature to target with a UAV. Too preliminary to say whether this feature is predictive of TGEN though. Recent talk I gave at a supercomputing (not meteorology) conference is here if you are interested.
 
By comparison with softball-size hail (~1.5lbs), the 2lb drone is heavier and it will interesting to see what happens the first time one of these is knocked out of the sky by bad weather while intentionally being flown in that environment, lands on someone's head, then kills them. Would a university or government research program be shielded from a crippling lawsuit?
 
If someone is outside when softball size hail is falling out of the sky, aren't they asking to get nailed in the head? And I completely agree with the diagnosis of streamwise vorticity using these things. That's what I would have focused the capstone on!
 
By comparison with softball-size hail (~1.5lbs), the 2lb drone is heavier and it will interesting to see what happens the first time one of these is knocked out of the sky by bad weather while intentionally being flown in that environment, lands on someone's head, then kills them. Would a university or government research program be shielded from a crippling lawsuit?

While I can envision the potential benefits....I'm with Steve. It would just be a matter of time before something goes quite wrong and the ambulance chasers will be "ringing the cash drawer" as they so fondly like to say.
 
Back
Top