eSpotter Phased Out?

I have to agree with Tim here - social networking has a place, but so does eSpotter as a separate entity. eSpotter by nature of using accounts verifies that the person submitting reports has had some training by NWS at some point; moreover, the data submitted in eSpotter is nicely organized and (usually) easy to interpret by NWS personnel at the office. Compare that to something like twitter, where any yahoo can submit what they think they're observing without even basic training, in any format they like - from what may be a very proper report with accurate observations to a full-book length narrative of a 'wedge tornado' made out of rain shafts.

I'm not saying the format eSpotter uses is infallible - there are plenty of spotters who, while they should know better, still don't follow the basic "only report what you can observe" rules and may get a bit eccentric in the excitement of a severe event, or opt to smash all the details in the "other information" box at the bottom and completely skip the fields. However, the chance of that happening isn't that high, especially comparing it to something like twitter or facebook where there's no standard formatting at all.
 
I don't think they really need to change anything about eSpotter, so why would it need more funding? It does its intended job quite well IMO, and I'm of the "if it's not broken, don't fix it" belief (especially when it comes to gov spending).

Well ... right now, the funding does not allow eSpotter to be nationwide. Offices that are not currently enrolled can't sign up for it. That's one simple way that more funding would make it even better.
 
Well ... right now, the funding does not allow eSpotter to be nationwide. Offices that are not currently enrolled can't sign up for it. That's one simple way that more funding would make it even better.

According the folks at eSpotter WFOs, can add themselves at anytime and are not aware of eSpotter
being dumped or replaced anytime soon. Just got the email from them Friday.

At last count over 99 WFO's were using eSpotter.

Tim
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry, the sentence did seem to run together some.

I contacted the email address for eSpotter. [email protected]
They responded.
A NWS liaison also answered the same last fall.


One thing I have learned is that each of the WFO's like to do their own thing many times.
The key is to contact them and ask them what they like to have used.

I can't see a portal like eSpotter going away. I can see it changing or morphing into something
better or at least different.

I do find the eSpotter form restricting, so our reports are mostly contained
in the comment section at the bottom using the TLCS reporting protocol.

I do wish it had a mobile phone version and I thought it was being looked into
but haven't checked on that lately.

Like any tool, it's only as good as the person using it.


Tim
 
According the folks at eSpotter (,) WFOs, can add themselves at anytime ...

Well ... maybe this has changed. The last time I discussed this with folks at our local office (Mount Holly, NJ ... a.k.a Philadelphia), I was told they could not sign up ... they had tried and it was rejected. Can you provide me (by PM might be appropriate) with a contact that can tell them how to accomplish signing up?
 
Rob...I missed you post. Probably would have asked the same. I don't like to duplicate (aka bug) the same people with the same questions. It's why I asked.

Tim...thanks for the PM.
 
Back
Top